Whiteriver, Arizona: Challistia Colelay Found Deceased, Authorities Launch Murder Investigation Immediately
WHITERIVER, Arizona — The White Mountain Apache Police Department confirmed that 16-year-old Indigenous girl, Challistia Colelay, was found deceased on November 3, 2025, on Fort Apache tribal land. Authorities have classified the case as a homicide, and an intensive investigation is now underway to determine the circumstances surrounding her death. The discovery of human remains has sent shockwaves through the community, prompting a swift law enforcement response and calls for justice from tribal leaders, family members, and local residents.
Challistia Colelay, a 16-year-old member of the White Mountain Apache Tribe, was described by family and friends as a vibrant, talented, and compassionate young girl. Her sudden and tragic passing has left relatives and classmates in profound grief, struggling to come to terms with the loss. The White Mountain Apache Police Department, in coordination with tribal authorities, is actively gathering evidence and following leads to identify any potential suspects involved in the incident.
The circumstances of Challistia’s death are under thorough investigation. Police have confirmed that the discovery of her body was made during a routine patrol on tribal land, but further details regarding the location and state of the remains have been withheld to protect the integrity of the investigation. Law enforcement officials have emphasized the sensitive nature of the case and requested the community’s cooperation in providing any information that may assist in the inquiry.
Tribal authorities have expressed deep sorrow over the tragedy, highlighting the need for vigilance and community awareness. Leaders of the White Mountain Apache Tribe have offered condolences to Challistia’s family and stressed the importance of supporting her loved ones during this difficult time. Community members have organized vigils and gatherings in her honor, reflecting the collective grief and determination to see justice served.
The investigation is being treated with the highest priority. Police are reviewing surveillance footage, interviewing potential witnesses, and working closely with federal agencies as necessary to ensure all leads are pursued. The authorities have urged anyone with information to come forward, emphasizing that even seemingly minor details could prove critical in solving the case.
Challistia’s death has also brought attention to broader concerns regarding the safety and protection of Indigenous youth in the region. Tribal leaders and community advocates have called for increased resources, community programs, and preventive measures to safeguard young people and prevent future tragedies. Public awareness campaigns have been launched to encourage reporting of suspicious activities and support for families affected by similar incidents.
While the investigation continues, the White Mountain Apache community remains united in mourning. Challistia Colelay’s life, though tragically cut short, is being honored through remembrance, prayers, and collective efforts to ensure that her story prompts meaningful action. Her family, friends, and community members are holding onto memories of her warmth, spirit, and promise, while seeking justice for her untimely passing.
#WhiteriverArizona #ChallistiaColelay #MurderInvestigation #JusticeForChallistia #WhiteMountainApache #CommunitySupport #ProtectYouth #InMemory
