Fort Payne, Alabama: Alisha Nichole Keller and Logan Cordale Brown Tragically Shot Inside Apartment
Fort Payne, Alabama — Alisha Nichole Keller, 27, and Logan Cordale Brown, 24, were discovered wounded in their apartment on the evening of November 9, 2025, in a devastating incident that shook the community. Emergency responders arrived shortly after a 5:59 p.m. call reporting shots fired at the housing authority complex on the 1300 block of Alabama Avenue NW. Officers quickly secured the scene and began rendering aid while awaiting medical personnel, but life-saving measures ultimately could not reverse the injuries both sustained.
Neighbors reported hearing gunfire and the commotion that followed, describing the quiet residential complex suddenly overtaken by sirens and flashing lights. Inside, the atmosphere was harrowing, as first responders worked tirelessly to provide emergency care in the kitchen where both victims had been shot. Despite their efforts, Alisha and Logan were pronounced deceased at the scene, leaving friends, family, and the Fort Payne community in deep mourning.
Investigators quickly determined that the shooting was linked to a domestic dispute. Law enforcement identified Jacob Eugene Mitchum, 27, of Oxford, Alabama, as the suspect. Mitchum had already left Fort Payne at the time of police response, attempting to return to his hometown. Fort Payne Police, Oxford Police, the Calhoun County Sheriff’s Office, and EMACC coordinated an effort to locate and apprehend him. Mitchum was ultimately found and arrested without resistance. He now faces charges of capital murder and remains held without bond at the DeKalb County Detention Center.
Authorities emphasized that no children were present in the apartment at the time of the incident and that no prior threats had been reported. Police confirmed that the dispute which led to the shooting had developed elsewhere, highlighting the sudden and unpredictable nature of the tragedy.
Community members have expressed shock and sorrow over the events, describing Alisha and Logan as vibrant, caring individuals whose lives were abruptly cut short. Friends remembered Alisha for her warmth and dedication to family and community, while Logan was praised for his kindness and commitment to those around him. Tributes began appearing on social media, offering condolences and sharing memories, reflecting the profound impact both had on those who knew them.
Law enforcement officials urged anyone with information regarding the events leading up to the shooting to come forward, stressing the importance of community involvement in ensuring justice. Meanwhile, support services have been made available to friends, neighbors, and colleagues affected by the incident, acknowledging the deep emotional toll of such a violent event.
As the investigation continues, Fort Payne residents are grappling with the reality of a loss that touches far beyond the immediate family. While Alisha Nichole Keller and Logan Cordale Brown will be remembered for their lives and the joy they brought to those around them, the community faces a period of reflection and healing. Authorities reiterated that thorough investigative work and legal proceedings will follow to hold the responsible party accountable.
May Alisha and Logan rest in peace, their memories honored by those who loved them, and may the community of Fort Payne find solace amid this heartbreaking loss.
