Long Island Mourns Aaron “Mont DaDon” Montemarano and Friend After Kayak Tragedy
Location & Victim Details
Riverhead, Long Island, New York – The Riverhead community is reeling following the tragic loss of Aaron “Mont DaDon” Montemarano, 25, and his close friend Shane Garcia, 27, who both passed after a kayaking accident off the eastern Long Island coast. Authorities confirmed that the two young men were recovered after an extensive multi-agency search operation that lasted several hours.
Aaron Montemarano, affectionately known by his music name “Mont DaDon,” was a rising local artist and beloved figure in Riverhead’s creative and social scene. Known for his charisma, musical talent, and deep community ties, Aaron’s passing has left an irreplaceable void in the hearts of family, friends, and fans. His friend, Shane Garcia, 27, was described by loved ones as a vibrant and loyal companion who shared Aaron’s love for the outdoors and adventure.
Both men were reportedly experienced on the water, often kayaking along Long Island’s south shorelines. What began as a routine day out on the water turned into a devastating event that now has two families and a community in mourning.
Incident & Recovery Efforts
According to Suffolk County Police, the incident began early on Sunday, November 2, 2025, when reports came in that two kayakers had not returned from an outing near the Peconic River and Reeves Bay area. Concerned friends and family alerted authorities when they failed to make contact that evening.
Search efforts immediately intensified, with assistance from Suffolk County Marine Bureau, Riverhead Police, local fire departments, and the U.S. Coast Guard. Rescue teams used boats, helicopters, and drones to scour the waters and nearby marshes.
By the following morning, authorities discovered one overturned kayak and several personal belongings floating near the shoreline. Shortly afterward, both Aaron and Shane were found unresponsive in separate locations near the bay area. Despite swift recovery and medical response efforts, both were pronounced deceased at the scene.
Investigators believe that strong winds and rapidly shifting currents may have contributed to the tragedy. Weather data showed gusts exceeding 25 mph that afternoon, which may have caused their kayak to capsize. Police confirmed that foul play is not suspected, and the case is being treated as a tragic accident.
Community Grief and Tributes
As news spread across Riverhead and surrounding towns, social media became flooded with tributes honoring both young men. Aaron “Mont DaDon” Montemarano was widely admired for his local music career, having performed at several Long Island venues and collaborated with emerging artists in the area. Friends remember him as “a light in every room,” someone who turned his passion for music into a platform for connection and positivity.
Shane Garcia’s friends described him as easygoing, adventurous, and deeply caring — always ready to help others and bring laughter to any gathering. The two shared a brotherly bond, often seen supporting one another’s creative and personal endeavors.
A memorial is being organized near the Riverhead waterfront, where candles, flowers, and handwritten notes have already begun to line the shoreline. Local artists and community members plan to host a celebration of life event featuring Aaron’s music in the coming weeks.
Family Statements & Ongoing Reflection
The Montemarano and Garcia families have expressed profound gratitude for the outpouring of support, prayers, and love from the community. They have also urged others to use water safety precautions, particularly as colder temperatures and unpredictable conditions increase the risks for small crafts like kayaks.
In a joint statement, Aaron’s parents shared, “Our son brought light and rhythm into our lives and the lives of everyone he met. His music and laughter will live forever.”
For many, this tragedy serves as a painful reminder of life’s fragility — but also of the deep connections that define small-town communities like Riverhead. The names Aaron Montemarano and Shane Garcia now stand as symbols of friendship, creativity, and the enduring spirit of togetherness.
Summary
The Long Island community of Riverhead continues to mourn Aaron “Mont DaDon” Montemarano, 25, and Shane Garcia, 27, following their tragic passing in a kayaking accident on November 2, 2025. Despite extensive rescue efforts by local and federal authorities, both men were found unresponsive near the Peconic River. Their loss has sparked an outpouring of love, remembrance, and a renewed call for water safety awareness.
#MontDaDon #AaronMontemarano #ShaneGarcia #RiverheadStrong #LongIslandCommunity
