Tippah County, Mississippi – A Virginia man accused of murdering his daughter’s boyfriend will face a retrial in March, this time in Calhoun County. Jeffrey Spence, 67, of Saltville, Virginia, is charged with capital murder in the November 30, 2022, shooting death of 36-year-old Kirby Carpenter.
Carpenter lived with Spence’s daughter, Caitlin, and their infant daughter in rural Tippah County at the time of the killing. Authorities say the incident occurred in the family home, leaving the community shocked and mourning the loss of a young father.
Spence’s first trial took place in Pontotoc County after a change of venue was granted due to pretrial publicity and community attention in Tippah County. The trial, however, ended in a mistrial after the jury deadlocked six to six on the charges.
Circuit Judge Kelly Luther presided over the initial trial and has now ordered a retrial to proceed in Calhoun County, citing the need for an impartial setting where both the prosecution and defense can present their cases fairly.
The decision to hold the retrial in Calhoun County marks a new chapter in a case that has drawn attention across multiple counties. Legal experts note that venue changes are often used in high-profile cases to reduce potential bias among jurors.
Spence remains in custody after the judge denied bond, citing the severity of the charge and concerns about public safety. He will continue to be held until the retrial begins in March, according to court records.
Family members of both the victim and the accused have been closely following the case. Carpenter’s relatives expressed their grief over the loss, describing him as a devoted partner and father whose life was tragically cut short.
The retrial will focus on the circumstances surrounding the November 2022 shooting. Prosecutors allege that Spence intentionally killed Carpenter in a confrontation at the home where Carpenter lived with Spence’s daughter. Defense attorneys maintain that there are questions surrounding the events that led to the fatal shooting.
Community members in Tippah County continue to process the impact of the crime. Local leaders and neighbors expressed concern over the violence, while also noting the importance of the justice system in determining the truth of the matter.
As the retrial approaches in Calhoun County, both legal teams are preparing for a case that will once again draw attention from the media and the public. The outcome will determine whether Spence faces the full penalties of a capital murder conviction or if the jury finds alternate grounds for acquittal or lesser charges.
